Extra Set of Referees to Blame for Worsening the Affordable Housing Crisis

Published On: August 19, 2024•4 min read•
The Roanoke Anthem Duplex by Fleetwood

Imagine that the National Football League (NFL) decided to insert cricket referees to officiate games alongside their football referees. Oh, and the cricket refs could create their own set of rules even though they know nothing about the game of football. It wouldn't make much sense, would it?  

This analogy is a pretty good example of what happened to the manufactured housing industry with the passing of the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA). In it, the Department of Energy (DOE) — the cricket referees — issued its own set of energy efficiency standards for the manufacturing housing industry. However, HUD (The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) — the football referees — had been the sole regulator of the manufactured housing industry since the passing of The National Manufactured Housing Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974 (NMHCSS). 

In 2016, in an effort to address ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) as it relates to the manufactured housing industry, the DOE created new standards that, once implemented, would add requirements that increase home prices, making it even more difficult for people to own their own home, and extending the affordable housing crisis.

An Odd and Ineffective Way to Tackle the Affordable Housing Crisis 

While the DOE's claim is that the standards will reduce monthly energy bills, they won't help people who can't afford to own a manufactured home. It's like touting the fuel savings you'll enjoy once you purchase the latest model Learjet. 

The DOE's proposed new standards will increase the cost of each home by thousands of dollars. According to the National Association of Realtors' 2023 Housing Affordability and Supply Report, for every home price increase of a thousand dollars, approximately 200,000 households are priced out of the housing market. So, if the new DOE standards increase manufactured home prices by $10,000 (a conservative estimate), resulting in two million additional families  who are unable to purchase a home. That's the population of the Cleveland metro area. These new standards would move the affordable housing crisis needle the wrong way by orders of magnitude. Even the DOE's own analysis confirms that implementation of their new standards will increase the price of manufactured homes. 

In addition, the new standards would mean manufactured homes will be held to higher efficiency standards than site-built homes, even though manufactured homes are every bit as energy efficient as a typical site-built homes. It's a perfect example of bureaucratic red tape.  

Why These New DOE Standards are Unnecessary 

Manufactured housing standards implemented by HUD have helped the industry stay energy conscious and efficient for years. HUD code regulations for construction and home design include standards for, among other things, energy efficiency, safety and health. These were born out of the creation of the Manufactured Housing Consensus Committee (MHCC), a body comprised of state officials, professionals and consumers. The MHCC makes recommendations to HUD, which, in turn, decides on what to add to its manufactured housing codes. 

In his 2023 testimony to the U.S. House of Representatives' Committee on Financial Services, Cavco CEO Bill Boor, who is Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Manufactured Housing Institute (MHI), stated, "MHI and its members always have supported, and will continue to support, energy conservation and efficiency efforts. We have a long history of consistent and ongoing quality and energy efficiency improvements. And we have a strong and positive working relationship with our regulator, HUD. This is an industry that agrees with the objective of continuing to improve energy efficiency, not one that needs to be dragged to do the right thing." 

The Good News — It's Easily Fixable 

To prevent the prices of manufactured homes from rising due to the new DOE standards, there's a simple solution — make all DOE standards related to manufactured housing subject to HUD's code process. This simple, effective solution will combat the affordable housing crisis by giving HUD the final authority on all standards. The result? More people will be able to afford manufactured homes AND they'll enjoy the lower energy costs, as well! 

Now that's a win-win.  

Need more Information about Manufactured Homes? 

If you'd like more information about manufactured, modular or park model homes, you've come to the right place. Contact the experts at Cavco. We've been building the industry's highest quality manufactured, modular and park model homes for almost 60 years. Check out the wide array of floor plans, features and amenities available. You'll like what you see.  

About the Author: Richard Arneson

Richard Arneson
Richard Arneson is a content manager in Cavco's marketing department. He has over 15 years of content writing experience, having worked for several large, multinational technology companies and written for digital marketing agencies throughout the world. He prides himself on taking subject matter that others may consider complicated, even boring, and bringing it to life and making it enjoyable to read and easy to understand.